Posted by
Brett K on Tuesday, January 08, 2008 11:00:00 PM
No one, and I mean no one, saw
this coming. Hillary Clinton won a close yet decisive victory over
Barack Obama in the New Hampshire Democratic primary. It was a major
surprise; as I type this, the RealClearPolitics poll average for NH
still has Obama in the lead by nearly 9 points.
The main reason
relates to the Republican results, which were somewhat surprising: John
McCain won, as expected, but by a somewhat greater and more decisive
margin than predicted by most. Romney was supposedly gaining ground,
but instead he lost by nearly the same amount he did in Iowa.
Both
results are connected to one major factor: Independent voters.
Registered Independents are allowed to vote for any party candidate in
the NH primary, and Independents have historically been very popular
with the moderate, mixed-bag John McCain (he even won in 2000 over
George W. Bush for the same reason). What pollsters were predicting was
a more even split in Independent votes to favor Obama (which was
accurate: the Independents that did vote Democrat voted for Barack);
however, nearly all the Independents voted Republican for McCain,
giving him a greater margin than expected and a narrow loss for Obama.
John
Edwards, too, had an inadvertent effect, causing a split of the
anti-Clinton vote between him and Barack. The fact that Edwards didn't
drop out tonight will continue to help her.
Outlook
For
the Democrats: I have been predicting Hillary Clinton as the Democratic
nominee ever since the beginning, and after this win I am going to
stand behind it. An Obama win is entirely plausible, but Clinton has
the organization and base that Obama now needs to build. She is leading
big in Nevada, California, and New York; but Obama still leads big in
South Carolina. It's impossible to say how the momentum will affect
either candidate.
For the Republicans: I cannot make any certain
predictions. Michigan is going to be a big barometer. It is a dead heat
between Romney and Huckabee for first, Giuliani and McCain for second.
Giuliani is the man to watch for the next month: he could pull ahead in
some of the bigger states such as Florida, California, and then a
handful on Super Tuesday.